On Tuesday 18 November the government published order No. 3407-r, signed the day before: the debt of 23 regions to the federal budget on budget credits is written off. The order's appendix gives each region's sum; we read the four-page scan in session and recomputed the column — the 23 lines add to exactly 59,613,459,962.06 roubles, the total the order states. On Wednesday at 09:35 the government's site announced the other half of the arrangement: 88.22 bn roubles of new treasury infrastructure credits for 22 regions, at 3% a year for 15 years. Eight regions appear on both lists. Old debt forgiven in the evening, new debt issued in the morning — and both flows pass beside the balance we measure.
Two thirds, up to what was spent
The write-off is not a gift against future behaviour; it is a receipt for money already spent. Under the scheme we set out on 29 August, two thirds of a region's budget-credit debt as of 1 March 2024 is written off up to the amount the region has actually spent on an approved list — utilities, resettlement from unsafe housing, public transport, investment projects. Order No. 3407-r applies that rule to 23 regions “in the amount of the funds actually directed by the constituent entities”, as its operative clause puts it. The government's release calls it writing off “two thirds of the debt”; the order's own text names no fraction, only the rouble total and its legal basis — part 17, article 15 of the law on executing budgets in 2026.
The largest write-offs go to Volgograd region (10.32 bn roubles), Sverdlovsk region (8.32 bn) and Omsk region (4.51 bn); the smallest, 17.6 mn, to the Nenets autonomous district. The order excludes three families of debt from forgiveness: credits for infrastructure projects, credits that topped up a region's single treasury account, and credits issued from the treasury's temporarily free cash for up to 15 years at 3 per cent a year. Keep that last description in mind — it returns the next morning.
A question from August, answered
With this order, the release says, the year's total reaches 366.6 bn roubles written off in 2026, used by 72 regions — some more than once. When we wrote up the mechanism on 29 August, the running total was one of the things no document would give: order No. 2266-r was a single order, not a running sum. The government has now named the sum itself. The arithmetic holds together: in his remarks to the cabinet, Mishustin said “over 300 billion roubles” had stayed with the regions before this order, and the new write-off of “almost 60 billion” brings the released total to 366.6 — 366.6 minus 59.6 is 307.0.
“And participants of the special military operation”
Explaining what the freed money had bought, the prime minister gave the cabinet a list:
“Previously they allocated resources not only to the modernisation of housing and utilities and the resettlement of citizens from unsafe housing. New public transport came into service there. They also supported the development of industry and participants of the special military operation and members of their families.”
The order's text contains no such purpose. The war clause lives one level up, in decree No. 1095 of 28 August: a region whose estimated fiscal capacity in 2026 did not exceed 0.9 may direct all the freed money to “expenses connected with the conduct of the special military operation”. There is no published list of which of the 23 clear that bar. What the prime minister's sentence establishes is that the head of government, presenting the year's 366.6 bn, lists war participants among the things the forgiven debt paid for — a purpose the order he was presenting never names.
Next morning, the credit window
On Wednesday morning Deputy Prime Minister Marat Khusnullin announced that the presidium of the government commission for regional development had approved the second stage of competitive selection for treasury infrastructure credits: 23 projects in 22 regions, 88.22 bn roubles for 2028–2030. His description of the instrument:
“This is long-term support for the regions on preferential terms — at 3% a year for 15 years.”
In total, he said, 322 projects in 85 regions have been approved since 2025, for 581.22 bn roubles. The release names all 22 regions and their sums — from 9.7 bn for Mordovia to 500 mn for Kalmykia — and, taking its two “about” figures at face value, those sums add to exactly 88.22 bn. Separately, outside the stage, the commission approved 7.8 bn for Nizhny Novgorod region under the limits for priority projects. The operator of the programme is the Territories Development Fund; the release does not give the date of the presidium's sitting, and the decision exists in public only as the government's account of it.
Now set the two days side by side. The credits Khusnullin describes — issued from the treasury's temporarily free cash, 15 years, 3 per cent — answer to the description order No. 3407-r excludes from forgiveness. The centre forgives the old debt it chose to forgive, keeps the new instrument's debt non-forgivable, and grew that instrument by 88.22 bn the morning after. Eight regions are on both lists:
| Region | Written off 18.11, bn | New credit approved 19.11, bn |
|---|---|---|
| Omsk region | 4.51 | 3.2 |
| Novosibirsk region | 3.49 | 1.5 |
| Perm territory | 3.49 | 8.0 |
| Orenburg region | 2.59 | 1.9 |
| Mordovia | 2.26 | 9.7 |
| Ryazan region | 1.52 | 1.1 |
| Irkutsk region | 1.09 | 2.5 |
| Khakassia | 0.91 | 2.4 |
For four of the eight — Perm, Mordovia, Irkutsk and Khakassia — the new approval exceeds what had just been forgiven.
What neither flow shows in our numbers
We measure the regions through the consolidated budget balance — revenue minus spending across the regional tier, as a rolling twelve-month total. A write-off is neither: the region's debt position improves without a rouble of revenue appearing. A treasury credit at 3 per cent when the key rate is 14% carries a subsidy inside it, and that subsidy never appears as a transfer either. As our guide puts it, a region that borrows from a bank and one that receives a federal write-off can report the same balance. The balance stands at a deficit of 1.192 trillion roubles through October, scoring 41 of 100. On the federal side, the order does not say how the foregone repayments will be shown in the federal budget — repayments that were already being deferred, interest-free, where they had been counted among the sources financing the deficit. The federal deficit runs at 3.0% of GDP on the same rolling-year basis; the strength index stands at 47.6 of 100, in the stress zone.
What the documents do not say
What remains. Neither the order nor the release gives any region's debt after the write-off, or what share of the 23 regions' total debt the 59.6 bn represents; “two thirds” is the release's phrase, not the order's.
Who cleared 0.9. There is no published list of which of the 23 regions meet the fiscal-capacity condition that decree No. 1095 set for spending freed money on the war; it would have to be computed from Minfin's equalisation tables.
What each region bought. The order writes off “in the amount of the funds actually directed”; the directions themselves exist in public only as the prime minister's spoken list.
The totals' document. 366.6 bn and 72 regions appear in a government release; no consolidated document carries them.
The credits' paper trail. No sitting date, no breakdown of how much of the 581.22 bn has been disbursed rather than approved — and no published act: the government's news page is, for now, the only record of the decision.