On 10 November the official portal published resolution No. 1485 of 10 November, signed by the prime minister, M. Mishustin. Its title gives nothing away — “On amendments to certain acts of the Government of the Russian Federation” — and the government issued no press release for it. The file is eleven pages: two of resolution, nine of amendments in twenty-one numbered items to the regulation on state price control for goods supplied under the state defence order. We read all eleven in this session.
Nineteen of the twenty-one items concern procedure: paper copies replaced by electronic submission “on removable optical machine-readable data carriers with a single-write function”, four-copy filings kept only for documents carrying state secrets, a cross-reference corrected from point 66 to point 67. Item 5 is different. It rewrites the sentence that sets the lowest profit the state will pay a defence manufacturer.
Item 5
“5. State the second paragraph of point 54 in the following wording: ‘For a prime contractor (contractor) in the case where the share of its own costs in the cost of production amounts to 20 percent or more, the planned profitability (profit) may not be less than 5 percent of the cost of production. At the same time, for such prime contractors (contractors) the minimum size of planned profitability (profit) must correspond to the requirements provided for by the first paragraph of this point, in the case where the said value, calculated applying the requirements provided for by this paragraph, is less than that calculated applying the requirements provided for by the first paragraph of this point.’”
The first sentence restates the rule already in force, but drops the words “at the same time” with which the paragraph had opened. The second sentence is new: where the 5% figure comes out lower than the floor in the paragraph above, the paragraph above governs.
The two floors
Point 54 applies when a defence price is built by the cost method — the method that adds a regulated profit margin on top of audited cost. It contains two floors, and until now it did not say which one wins.
The first paragraph, in the wording given it by resolution No. 935 of 21 May 2022, sets the margin as a sum of two parts and puts a floor under it:
“no more than 1 percent of planned brought-in costs and no more than 25 percent of the organisation's planned own costs for the supply (including production) of goods, but not less than 10 percent of the organisation's planned own costs for the supply (including production) of goods.”
The second paragraph — the one item 5 replaces — adds a different floor for contractors that do a substantial share of the work themselves: not less than 5 percent of total cost.
The two are measured against different bases, so which binds depends on how vertically integrated the manufacturer is. Write total cost as 100 and the contractor's own share of it as k:
| own costs as share of total cost | floor from paragraph one (10% of own costs) | floor from paragraph two (5% of total cost) | which binds |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20% | 2.0% of cost | 5.0% of cost | paragraph two |
| 40% | 4.0% of cost | 5.0% of cost | paragraph two |
| 50% | 5.0% of cost | 5.0% of cost | they are equal |
| 60% | 6.0% of cost | 5.0% of cost | paragraph one |
| 80% | 8.0% of cost | 5.0% of cost | paragraph one |
The crossover is at exactly half: 0.10 × k exceeds 0.05 when k exceeds 0.5. Below it, the 5% rule is the generous one and nothing changes. Above it, the new sentence lifts the guaranteed minimum — to 6% of cost for a contractor doing 60% of the work itself, and to 8% of cost, three-fifths more than 5%, for one doing 80%.
Who that is
The contractors above the line are the ones that make most of a product in their own shops rather than assembling bought-in units. On the face of the new wording, the direction is mechanical: the same audited cost carries a larger guaranteed margin. If the explicit priority changes practice, the state pays more for the same article. Against an unchanged appropriation for the National Defence section, that buys fewer articles; against an unchanged physical programme, it costs more money.
The budget direction is not hidden in the arithmetic. The text now expressly gives the higher floor to the most integrated suppliers. Whether that changes what the state actually paid before this resolution is the central uncertainty set out below.
The repeal that is not what it looks like
Point 2 of the resolution repeals “point 11 of the amendments … approved by resolution of the Government of the Russian Federation of 23 August 2021 No. 1388”. A repealed 2021 amendment sitting next to a rewritten profit floor invites the guess that the thing being removed is what held the floor at 5%. It is not.
We retrieved resolution 1388 from the register (published 26 August 2021, seven pages) and read its amendments in full. Point 11 reads:
“11. Supplement point 128 with sub-item ‘k’ as follows: ‘k) the registration number of the price determined as the base price, and the base year (in the case of application of the base-price indexation method and the method of indexation by base cost items).’”
It is a field in a price registration record. Item 20 of today's amendments deletes that same sub-item from point 128, and point 2 of the resolution tidies up the 2021 instruction that created it. The two acts touch the profit floor nowhere. Point 54's second paragraph was never in resolution 1388.
What else moved in the same text
Three other items change money or timing rather than paperwork.
Forty working days. Items 3(a) and 17 insert the same new paragraph into points 50 and 125: where a sole supplier asks the state customer to extend the period for reviewing its documents, the customer extends it, and “the maximum period by which the review period is extended on such applications is 40 working days.” Price agreement in the defence order gets a formal, supplier-initiated delay it did not have.
A registered price becomes a ceiling. Item 21 replaces, in the second paragraph of point 130, the words “the registered price” with “a price not exceeding the registered price”. Registration had fixed a number; it now fixes an upper bound, with room beneath it.
A ten-month deferral. The resolution takes effect on publication with two exceptions, named in point 4: the fourth paragraph of item 12 and the sixth paragraph of item 18 start on 1 September 2027. Both are the same instruction — that the state customer send documents to the Federal Antimonopoly Service “by the same means by which they were submitted”. The transmission rule is postponed; the price rule is not.
The same section, the same day
Hours before resolution 1485 appeared, the same portal published order No. 3275-r of 10 November, one page, signed by the same prime minister. It directs to the National Guard budget appropriations held by the finance ministry under the sub-section “Other matters in the field of national defence” of the “National Defence” section, in an amount of up to 249,963.9 thousand roubles — about 250 million — to reimburse the cost of leave travel for its servicemen and for those serving in it with police ranks. The purpose is written into the operative sentence:
“…in order to prevent the formation of accounts payable.”
Two acts, one day, one section of the budget. One raises the guaranteed margin the state pays its arms manufacturers. The other redirects appropriations already provided to the finance ministry under that subsection so that a service does not fall behind on holiday travel claims. The second is small enough that its size is not the point; what it shows is a budget being managed bill by bill at the line-item level, inside the section that is the state's declared first priority.
The money here is owed to servicemen for their own travel, not to a company against an invoice. The order therefore sits outside our overdue receivables series, which counts overdue amounts organisations owe one another and which our guide to corporate arrears explains. What it shows is narrower but still worth seeing: the state is tracking an obligation it has already incurred and settling it before it turns into arrears.
What this means for the series we track
Nothing moves today. This morning's ingest recorded no change in any of the eight indicators, and the strength index stands at 46.6 of 100, in the stress zone.
The federal budget deficit is the series this resolution bears on, through the spending side. It stands at a rolling twelve-month deficit of 7,342 billion roubles through September, 3.2% of GDP, scoring 66 of 100 against a pre-war anchor that was itself a surplus — 524.3 billion roubles, or 0.34% of GDP, in 2021 — and a trouble line registered in advance at 10% of GDP. Our guide to the deficit explains how the series is built, and our guide to military spending sets out what is and is not counted in the National Defence section.
A price rule does not enter that series as a number. It enters as a direction: the text now assigns every unit bought under the cost method from a highly integrated supplier a larger guaranteed margin. If that changes practice, the bill lands in the same section of the same budget that the deficit measures.
What we do not know
Whether this raises prices or only writes down what was already done. This is the central uncertainty and we will not resolve it here. Before today the two floors sat in consecutive paragraphs joined by the words “at the same time”, which can be read as making both apply — in which case the binding floor was already the larger of the two and the amendment changes nothing in practice. The new wording deletes “at the same time” from the opening of the paragraph and then states the priority explicitly. That governments legislate to settle disputed readings is a reason to think the question was live; it is not evidence of how the Federal Antimonopoly Service, which registers these prices, actually decided it. We could not obtain an explanatory note: no press release was issued, and the draft's card on regulation.gov.ru could not be opened from this environment.
How much money it is. The share of own costs in total cost is not published for the defence industry, by firm or in aggregate, so the number of contractors above the 50% line is unknown and the budget effect cannot be computed from this document or any other we have. Any figure put on it would be invented.
What the ten-month deferral is for. The two paragraphs held back to 1 September 2027 concern how documents reach the antimonopoly service. Why that needs ten months, the resolution does not say.
Whether the National Guard shortfall was real. “Up to 249,963.9 thousand roubles” is a ceiling, not a disbursement, and “in order to prevent the formation of accounts payable” is standard wording in such orders. It is consistent with an actual gap and equally consistent with procedural caution. The order cites no earlier order of its kind, and no consolidated record of such acts is published, so we cannot say how many there have been this year or what they sum to.